We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
RSS FeedGovernance

MPs slam HMRC for “cosy” deals with corporates

A report by the Public Accounts Committee said the taxman must address “systemic issues”

Article comments

A committee of MPs has criticised HMRC for governance breaches in its tax negotiations with some companies and for treating large corporate "more favourable" than other taxpayers.

In a new report the Public Accounts Committee said that there were "systemic issues" at HM Revenue and Customs that had to be dealt with to avoid the same tax officials negotiating and approving tax settlements with corporates for outstanding tax payments.

"The department has left itself open to suspicion that its relationships with large companies are too cosy," the PAC report said.

The report singled out Dave Hartnett, permanent secretary for tax, for failing to handle tax negotiations with some big companies properly and with little public scrutiny.

"We have serious concerns about how the department handled some cases involving large settlements, where governance arrangements were bypassed or overlooked until it was too late. In some cases the same officials negotiated and approved the settlements, which is clearly unacceptable," the PAC report said.

It added: "There needs to be proper separation between the negotiation of tax settlements and the authorization of such settlements."

MPs said the Revenue's duty was to secure value for money but in one case because of governance failings a loss of up to £8 million in interest was made. The PAC also said there was evidence that "the total value of interest payable in respect of this particular settlement could be as high as £20 million".

Tax lawyers suggest that the report signals the end for similar deals being made with HMRC for other corporates in the future.

"This report has enormous implications for how HMRC deals with the largest companies. It is important that HMRC stops making deals behind closed doors without following a transparent process which is the same for all companies," Jonathan Levy, head of the tax disputes group at City law firm RPC, said.

"A fair and transparent system, in which all taxpayers, large and small, know where they stand and are treated equally, will promote certainty and confidence in the UK tax system," Levy, a former senior member of HMRC Solicitor's Office, added.



MPs slam HMRC for “cosy” deals with corporates

What makes a good board report?

What makes a good board report?

Examining how CFOs can improve the way they report back to the boardmore ..

Vodafone buys out partner's stake in Indian unit

Mobile giant acquires the remaining 11% it did not already ownmore ..

Financial advisers not being clear enough on charges, says watchdog

FCA’s review found 73% of firms failed to provide adequate informationmore ..

EU data retention rules violate privacy rights, EU court rules

Rules requiring telcos to retain communications metadata are disproportionate, the court saidmore ..

Examining the issue of corporate litigation funding

Litigation funding is a very useful tool for CFOs but not a panacea for all legal mattersmore ..

Corporate governance: A catalyst for innovation

Corporate governance is a powerful tool in a C-suite executive’s arsenalmore ..

Send to a friend

Email this article to a friend or colleague:

PLEASE NOTE: Your name is used only to let the recipient know who sent the story, and in case of transmission error. Both your name and the recipient's name and address will not be used for any other purpose.

In Depth
How M&A teams can create value by challenging the CEO

How M&A teams can create value by challenging the CEO

A typical “hold” period of nine to 18 months can generate increased sale value more ..

In Depth
What every company needs to do about big data?

What every company needs to do about big data?

In the first of a three part series, Pat Brans explores just how big 'big data' will get? more ..


* *